Forum Archive
Historical Topic: This discussion is from 2007. For current info, check out our updated guides.

bad deal_be careful

Started March 19, 2007 · 37,730 views · 18 posts
Quote:
WSU student says Mexican police tortured, extorted him
WSU student says his sunny vacation in Mexico turned into a nightmare after police kidnapping.


Jacob Jones

The Daily Evergreen

Published: 03/19/2007 00:00:00
A 21-year-old WSU student returned early from vacation in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, with a terrifying tale.

Senior economics major Andrew DeLorenzo said he was finishing up a night of drinking with six friends at a downtown Puerto Vallarta club on March 12 when he was seized by Mexican police officers. DeLorenzo said he was then bound, robbed and abused for more than 12 hours.

“It seemed so surreal,” he said.

DeLorenzo and six friends flew into the city on March 11 for spring break. He said they finished up their first night in the city outside a club on the downtown boardwalk at about 3 a.m. the next day. The group drank heavily throughout the night getting “trashed,” he said.

His friends were blackout drunk, he said. So as the least intoxicated one of the group, DeLorenzo said, he stepped away from his friends to ask a group of six or seven officers about taxi service back to their hotel.

DeLorenzo said uniformed officers told him he was under arrest, handcuffed him and put him in the back of a beat-up truck. He said he expected the officers to ask him for a bribe.

“I didn’t even think about fighting at that time,” he said.

Mexican officials told DeLorenzo’s family he was not seized by officers, but was found lying on the street with several injuries. Officials told the family he was taken to multiple hospitals for treatment and was only arrested when he became violent.

DeLorenzo said officers did take him to what appeared to be a doctor’s office, but his injuries were the result of how officers treated him. He said officers beat him with a weighted sock and struck him repeatedly. He said officers also demanded, in limited English or Spanish, the approximately $60 he had with him and personal information including his bank account PIN.

Meanwhile, his friends had gone back to their hotel and assumed DeLorenzo was busy with either trouble or a girl, he said. After two or three hours and a shift change of police officers, DeLorenzo tried to escape by hitting one of the officers. The officers then beat and restrained him, he said. “My legs are all scratched up from them dragging me,” he said.

DeLorenzo said individuals in the office then attempted to break his arm and threatened to cut off his head with a bonesaw. A person at the office also injected him with an intravenous solution, but missed the vein causing his arm to swell with fluid, he said.

He said he was then moved to a cell where a well-dressed man confronted him with a written confession for allegedly breaking a window and demanded his signature. At that point, DeLorenzo was able to get in contact with the local U.S. Consular Agency, he said.

Consular Agent Kelly Trainer called DeLorenzo’s family and told them he was under arrest for breaking a window. His mother, Lynn DeLorenzo, said the agent told her they could pay $1,000 for the window and get him out or they could let him sit as he waited for a court hearing.

“The easiest way for us was to just pay the $1,000,” Lynn DeLorenzo said.

The family wired him the money and he flew home early. Since then, Lynn DeLorenzo said they have tried to get the Mexican government to explain what happened. They filed a verbal complaint to the Mexican Consulate in Seattle. The consulate could not be reached for comment Sunday afternoon.

She said her son’s story sounds like a script to a bad movie, but he gets too upset for it to be fake.

“He would break down and cry telling me this story,” she said.

She said the family has taken Andrew DeLorenzo to several doctors to look at his injuries, including three X-rays of his swollen arm. The doctors determined the unknown IV fluid was the source of the swelling, but none of the Mexican doctors in the police reports state they administered any intravenous drugs.

The family said police statements regarding his custody have changed throughout the past week.

“It makes no sense at all,” Lynn DeLorenzo said. “I don’t think we’re ever going to prove this.” Unauthorized charges to Andrew DeLorenzo’s bank account have arisen in Mexico since he returned home, she said.

The family plans to file a complaint to the U.S. Department of State and hopes other college students on vacation do not face similar situations.

“You just really can’t be careful enough,” she said.



http://www.dailyevergreen.com/story/21717

I believe the boy story
just don´t get plastered
especially on the malecon
asking a police for cab
is a no no
true about police brutatly
a sin
be careful when you want to get bombed out
Advertisement

Planning your trip?

Explore our comprehensive travel guide for up-to-date info on Puerto Vallarta.

View Travel Guide
My take was the guy was so drunk that he remembers little and is just trying to make this a big issue. He should sober up and then go back to school and forget the whole incident.
Well i have seen this post on several boards, and especially on the others the boys story is being completely dismissed.

we cannot know the facts from here, but in my view it would be a critical mistake to dismiss his claims wholesale.

Suppose he broke a window. Suppose he was obnxious. Is it then ok to inject him with some unknown caustic liquid? He certainly has scars.

I live north of PV as many of you know. And I had an experience with the police in this beautiful country about two months ago. Perhaps this is why I am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.

At 3 am my dogs went nuts left my bedroom where I sleep and chased a man off my property. He had broken in thru our gate on the beach and was in the house.

My mother was on oxygen in the next room. I got up and this man stopped running just outside the gate and simply stood there.

I called the police. They told me that they would be changing shifts in a couple hrs and so noone would be avaialble until dayight. I was shocked.

I got the courage or stupidity up to go ask the guy what he was doing. He was an english speaking non-mexican man.

He appeared to be crazy or on drugs. He said that he got i the gate but all the dogs didnt leave -- was his goal for them all to leave - did he have a goal who knows. he refused to leave.

I called the police again. and again and again. 4 hrs later he was still there and would not leave. I called a good friend (75 yo ex cop woman from the states - tough as nails) for advice. She said she would run to bucerias and find a police officer.

I waited another hour noone showed. My gardeners showed up and so i left them standing guard and i drove to bucerias to find the one dog that took off.

I returned in 15 minutes. The gardeners were yelling and upset. My friend the 75 yo women showed up alone and confronted the guy. He grabbed her by the throat, shook her and threatened to kill her. she broke away and left in her car again. (she later told me he wasnt squeezing all that hard)

I called the police again. The man was still there thrashing his arms wildly in the air. They said come in and make a report when i like and that they didnt have time to investigate until 11 am.

Finally my friend returned with a preventiva police car following her. They got out of the car, looked toward the beach at the guy, and said let us know if he goes back into the house and they got ready to leave!

At this point i said hey what is the problem. this guy breaks into my house and theatens to kill her and is standing right there on the beach and you wont do anything, This is insane.

I was then informed that I was about to be arrsted for raising my voice to a police officer - and i could see right then and there that I would be the guy getting beaten or worse.

I walked away.

Another car arrived. All the neighbors came out. With the public pressure. They cuffed the guy and left.

My friend went to the station to amend the final report. No arrests were made. There was no record of the incident. Noone knows where the man is. It was as tough the incident never happened. We called the counsulate since the offender was american and could have been ill or on drugs needing medical care who knows.

Kelly trainer was out of town. They promised to investigate. Honestly dont know of they did or not but they have not contacted us.

Locals now tell me that the police know the guy and he buys drugs from them. Dont know it thats true or not.

I love living here most of the time.... but.... there is no law as most of us know it. If you believe otherwize you are naive.

If a problem arrizes - maybe the police will help, maybe they will ignore it, maybe you will end up the victim like this boy claims to have been.

So like I said to start. Maybe the boy contributed to his situation a lot or a little. But i for one will not dismiss his claims as his own fault.

While there may be many good police here, there are too many corrupt \"animals\" for lack of a better word wearing police uniforms.

\"be careful\" is the best advice i can give when dealing with police here.

Jeff
was that sandy
who tried to help
tough old lady
she doesn´t stop
Just read on another board that a bunch of cops got fired yesterday. No word yet, if that has anything to do with this or not.
2 Amazing stories...

Something happened to Andrew... He was beaten and abused and he was in a Police cell and he was charged...
He also did contact Agent Kelly Trainer at the local U.S. Consular Agency...
I tend to believe the kid and I hope he and his family continue with the proper help to investigate what happened..
He either had self inflicted wounds...Was beaten up by? or he is telling the truth and was abused by the cops
Police brutality happens at times in Canada and the States... why so hard for some to not believe it happend in beloved PV.

Even ..if..he did break a window there is no way he deserved to be beaten..


and.....Sandy sounds like a gem... :)
Advice
Drunk and stupid = trouble no matter where you reside . Try watching the TV show , \"Cops\" , some time - most of the arrests are drunks or crackheads . One thing to get wasted at the hotel or resort but to go out in public like that is asking for trouble especially in a foreign land.
My two cents worth
Well I did some investigating on this story,because like many, I want to believe him but there are to many holes in the story.
So what I found was his side like you all have, and then I found what seems to be a local campus newspaper for wsu but I am not
100% sure on that. Anyways they reported what they read in the daily evergreen but went on to do some investigating into his facebook
( I didnt know what this was so I looked it up and its a social network website designed for college and university students).Well It
isnt very nice what they found he had in there, He belongs to a fraternity,I can not say on this forum what is written it is very graphic
tatseless, mean spirited and so on I do have the link so if anyone wants it I will pass it on through pm. But be warned it isnt nice.It
gave me a whole new look on this guy.Now I am not saying this warrents the bruises but this happens everywhere U.S,CANADA
And sometimes ppl catch it on tape.Criminals in winnipeg told stories of the telephone book treatment in the elevator.

But the one thing that does bug me is how ppl go after the parents you now what, if it was my child I would do everything in my power
to find out what the heck happened and you know why because thats my child( whether there 10yrs old or 40) thats my blood and as a parent It is my job to
find out the truth.Now the kid probally doesnt remember alot so in this situation your not going to know the whole truth which as a
parent really sucks but to lash out at the parents is beyond me yes they have a bad ass son but they paid the fine got him home relatively
safe, thats there job if it seems he caused this and brought it on himself then make him pay the 1000 dollars back, teach him what it costs to be
irresponsible. Does it justify police brutality no.

Bottom line is none of us know this kid so we will never know the truth. Is pv safe, just as safe as anywhere else. The first time my children go away as adults
to a foriegn country I will be with them as my mom was with me and I will teach them how to have a great time even with drinking but doing it safely.
Michele,

Just to clearify, I was not going after his parents in my comments. I was merely pointing out the fact that his mom calling from Washington to the police demanding to know what happened is a waste of time. First of all she will be lucky if she can find anyone who speaks/understands english well enough to understand her. That is why we have the US consulate (Kelly Trainor) and the Canadian Consulate. They are the ones with at least a little bit of clout to get answers to what happened to one of their citizens in PV. His mother is just wasting her time and money and she needs to have the consulate working on it. Mothers yelling and screaming in defense of OUR children, as right as we feel we are for doing it, never gets alot of positive results.

In my post I said I raised two sons and I know some of the stunts they pulled, luckily I never had to bail them out of jail. I also know some of the stunts I pulled as a young adult, my problem was with my dad being a police officer I \"ALWAYS\" got caught. Someone always told my dad and then I got to face the \"Do you have something you want to tell me question\". To which I always replied \"NO, not really\". He would give me his \"look\" and I could never keep a straight face no matter what I was trying to convince him of. :lol:
Kat

Im sorry I should have said I wasnt referring to your comment like I said I did some investigating on the net I read all the other boards and articles and what ppl were saying and not just on this issue just in general any time there is an incident in a foreign country. I only belong to and post on this board so this is where I put my 2 cents in once in awhile. I agree with what you posted and I should have said that I dont take jabs at anyone here I was just making a comment in general about what I have read all over.


I had a friend whos dad was a police officer to so I hear you on that :D
Once again I apologize.
Michelle,

No need to apologize, I just wanted everyone to know I was not finding fault with his mother wanting to know who did this to her son. I just think she is taking the wrong avenue to find out, the mexican police are never going to pay any attention to her. Between not being trained to do PR to satisfy the tourists (if it had happened in the states people would be demonstrating outside the police station demanding answers) and partly because of the machismo in Mexico, women voicing their opinion get ignored, it is a cultural thing. If the police are going to give any answers at all it will be with a little pressure from the American Consulate.
I understand like with my situation when I was there the airport police all of a sudden couldnt speak english anymore to me and my mom.Luckily my friend had come to say good bye to us so he translated and it ended up I was allowed to leave with him and over the next few days dealt with the canadian embassy and another guy that I cant remember his name.
Quite frankly, getting beaten when you are young and stupid can help you get older and wiser in a hurry, which is a good thing. Sounds like the kid probably needed a lesson in real life to me.
lyrihn..you have said it best what I believe...
Quote
I find it quite amazing how well everyone appears to know this kid from a few snippets here and there.
Yes he was drinking, Yes he or someone who knows him has posted a sexually graphic but nonviolent online blurb, yes his story may have inconsistancies or holes -- none of this surprises me.

I dont feel i know him at all and beatings are just unacceptable - period.

...........................
To try and justify physical violence (abuse) is wrong..

and kat as for inconsistencies in a press story it is many times the reporters that screw things up...
M:-(

I lost my head for a minute, no one else is entitled to an opinion.
Awww Kat.. :? Please do not again turn this into something it is not...
You were allowed your opinion...
We said ours...
It is also OK to have a different opinion and not follow the crowd...
Nothing more my dear nothing is going on.. :) so get your head back OK... :D

I have found this to be an interesting thread...
... if Kelly Trainor was helping him and called his mom, she would be the one dealing with the police for answers, not his mom calling from Washington? That is part of Kelly’s job.
In my experience (and those of my American and Canadian friends living in Vallarta ), the US and Canadian consulates are both equally useless when it comes to helping victims of violent crime.

Thankfully, health matters are a different story. They can be very helpful in those instances.
One would think at the very least an investigation would have been done and those officers involved would have been named and suspended with or without pay pending further analysis of the event.

Noone deserves such treatment. There is a very large difference between battle scars earned in a drunken scuffle with cops and the injection of a caustic chemical into ones veins. This cant be denied as it is clearly seen on video. Thats appalling and disgusting.

I am a little shocked at the stance taken by some on this subject.